[UPDATE] Google is making schools choose between AI and access to its Search engine

[UPDATE: Google has clarified that educators can choose to disable any of the AI products, independent of Google Search. Here is what the company shared in a post on X:
Schools are in control: They can choose to turn ON one, two, or all of these services individually.
The original story is as follows]

Google says it wants to give schools more control over how students use AI. But its proposed solution comes with a rather extraordinary condition: schools that opt to block AI entirely will also lose access to Google Search on student accounts. The conclusion is that schools can say no to Google’s AI, but they may have to give up one of the most fundamental tools students use to learn and research online.

The change, reported by The New York Times, is expected to take place early next year. Google is responding to concerns from parents and educators who want more control over how children interact with AI, the company said. But linking access to Search to acceptance of AI raises an uncomfortable question: is Google really giving schools a choice, or making it harder for them to say no?

Google gives AI opt-out, but Search is stuck in the middle

Google said it will disable artificial intelligence features in its education software for kindergarten through 12th grade by default, unless school administrators choose to turn them on. That sounds like a good compromise to me after months of educators fighting back. The catch is that schools that choose to block AI entirely will also lose access to Google Search.

“Search and AI are now closely intertwined,” said Chris Phillips, Google’s vise president for education. Schools that block AI will see Search become unavailable to students, with a message explaining that the school has blocked access.

That is a particularly troubling compromise. Search is not an experimental AI feature that schools can afford to miss. It is a basic research tool that enables students to find information, compare sources, and work on assignments. Removing it because administrators don’t want AI in the classroom essentially ties access to one technology to the acceptance of another.

The decision is also important because Google is a behemoth in American schools, with its Chromebooks and services such as Gmail, Docs, and Classroom widely used. Lina Khan, the former chair of the Federal Trade Commission, criticized the move, saying that Google was using its dominance of the search market to pressure schools into adopting its AI.

Schools need control, not an AI-or-nothing deal.

The timing is important. Parents and teachers are increasingly concerned about the use of AI chatbots in classrooms, especially the risk that the tools will promote cheating, generate incorrect information, and undermine independent thinking. New York City and Los Angeles school districts have severely limited generative AI for students on school devices.

Google has changed how it does things, too. In August, it turned on AI features by default in Classroom for schools that had granted students separate access to Gemini. That decision angered school administrators who wanted to control when students used the technology. Now Google is reversing that change.

Starting in early 2027, schools that permit AI will have two search choices: the usual experience with AI Overviews and AI chats, or a Guided Learning mode built around Gemini. The latter is meant to guide students through topics, not just give them the answers. School version teachers will also be able to view transcripts of the chatbot.

Those options may be helpful, but they don’t address the root of the problem. Schools that want traditional search without generative AI shouldn’t have to lose Search altogether. Google has every right to put AI in its products, but education systems should have the right to decide whether that technology has a place in their classrooms. If the choice is between accepting AI or not having access to Search, it’s hard to call that a meaningful choice.

RELATED COVERAGE: